Well....
I wanted to love this. The colors are fantastic, vibrant and smooth. Application is easy. I have no complaints whatsoever about the highlighting end. But this SMEARS. Like, wow. I use an eye base underneath and halfway through the day the line is mirrored on my upper eyelid. Not a good look. I'll use this till I run out but I'm not repurchasing. A waterproof version or improved formula would be awesome!
Response from Katelyn at Jane Iredale
May we ask if you’re currently applying Mystikol with a brush? If not, try applying the Mystikol with an eye liner brush. When loading the brush with product, be sure to take the product off the sponge tip applicator, not from the cap. The Mystikols are highly pigmented, so only a very small amount is needed. Using the brush will allow you to control the amount of product used, and can help get a tight line. Setting the Mystikol with a powder eye shadow or applying it over the shadow or a light application of foundation will also help increase the length of wear. Finally, try a light spray of Hydration Spray after application, and this may help set the liner.