This is an innovative and interesting product, it's fun to use and it's a great value bc it lasts FOREVER. The pigmentation of the liner is incredibly vibrant. I have Lapis Lazuli, which is a deep sapphire color. The highlighter is great for inner eye corner. My only complaint is that this SMUDGES! I apply it with a flat liner brush, I've tried it with and without an eye primer, I've set it with setting powder (this helped the most), but nothing fully keeps it from ending up in a mirrored ring on my eyelid and a little below my eyes. I wish it didn't make me look so sick and tired by the end of the day. I will probably still buy the Emerald color and the citrine and survive the smudging, but any advice would be welcome!